Shay Given Praises Arsenal’s Noni Madueke as ‘Miles Ahead’ of Chelsea’s Garnacho

Shay Given says Arsenal’s Noni Madueke is “miles ahead” of Chelsea’s Garnacho, sparking debate over Premier League transfer decisions.

Former Manchester City and Newcastle United goalkeeper Shay Given has claimed that Madueke is miles ahead of Garnacho, following Chelsea’s decision to sell Noni Madueke to Arsenal and replace him with Alejandro Garnacho from Manchester United. The former Premier League goalkeeper shared his thoughts on BBC Radio 5 Live.

“Madueke is miles ahead of Garnacho right now.”

This statement has sparked debate among fans and pundits, especially in light of Chelsea’s recent transfer decisions.

Chelsea’s Transfer Shake-Up

Chelsea sold Noni Madueke to Arsenal for £52 million. In his place, they signed Alejandro Garnacho from Manchester United for £40 million. Garnacho, just 21 years old, is considered a rising star but has yet to prove himself consistently at the top level.

Madueke, on the other hand, has quickly impressed at Arsenal. His performances under Mikel Arteta have shown maturity, creativity, and strong chemistry with teammates.

Shay Given isn’t alone in his opinion. Chris Sutton also questioned Chelsea’s decision, noting Madueke’s previous connection with Cole Palmer. He suggested that selling Madueke to a direct rival could backfire.

However, former Chelsea winger Florent Malouda offered a more optimistic view. He believes Garnacho has the potential to grow and follow a similar path to Palmer, who has flourished since joining Chelsea.

Chelsea’s decision to swap Madueke for Garnacho raises questions about their long-term strategy. While Garnacho has talent, Madueke’s current form and Premier League experience give Arsenal an edge.

If Garnacho adapts quickly, Chelsea may still benefit. But for now, Shay Given’s assessment reflects the general sentiment: Arsenal got the better deal.

 

Want more Arsenal updates? Visit our homepage.

All links on ArsenalTalks Shop are affiliate links. We may earn commissions that support our content—at no extra cost to you. Read our full Affiliate Disclosure for more information.