Jamie Carragher Names Declan Rice as Top Midfielder Despite Gary Neville’s Moises Caicedo Claim

Jamie Carragher hails Declan Rice as the Premier League’s top midfielder, countering Gary Neville’s claim that Moises Caicedo leads the pack.

Jamie Carragher has named Declan Rice as top midfielder in the Premier League, openly disagreeing with Gary Neville’s claim that Chelsea’s Moises Caicedo currently holds that title.

The debate reignited after a weekend filled with standout Premier League performances. Gary Neville praised Chelsea’s Moises Caicedo for his brilliant goal against Liverpool, boldly declaring him the best midfielder in the league.

Speaking on his podcast, Neville said:

“He’s the best midfield player in the league at this moment in time… Caicedo is performing like that.”

Jamie Carragher, however, offered a different view during Sky Sports’ Extra Time. The former Liverpool defender insisted that Declan Rice edges ahead of Caicedo based on all-round quality.

“Oh, he is very close, but he wouldn’t be the best for me,” Carragher said. “If you’re talking all-round midfielder, Declan Rice would just pip Caicedo. I think he’s got that extra bit of quality with the ball.”

Carragher Praises Rice’s All-Round Game

Carragher’s argument for Declan Rice as top midfielder rests on his versatility, technical ability, and consistency. While Caicedo has impressed since the turn of the year, Carragher believes Rice offers more in possession and decision-making.

Rice’s influence at Arsenal continues to be vital in their title challenge. His leadership, midfield control, and ability to score crucial goals, such as his recent strike against West Ham, demonstrate why Carragher considers him the Premier League’s most complete midfielder.

Gary Neville, meanwhile, bases his assessment on current form. He highlighted Caicedo’s defensive tenacity, energy, and improvement under Chelsea manager Enzo Maresca. Neville sees Caicedo as the league’s most dominant midfielder right now, even ahead of Rodri and Rice.

A Tight Race at the Top

Both pundits agree it’s a close contest. Carragher’s preference for Declan Rice as top midfielder reflects a broader view of long-term consistency and balance, while Neville’s support for Caicedo emphasizes short-term form and intensity.

The discussion highlights the Premier League’s incredible depth in midfield talent. With Rice and Caicedo both playing key roles for their clubs, the battle for midfield supremacy looks set to continue all season.

Want more Arsenal updates? Visit our homepage.

All links on ArsenalTalks Shop are affiliate links. We may earn commissions that support our content—at no extra cost to you. Read our full Affiliate Disclosure for more information.