Jamie Carragher Changes His Tune Over Player He Claimed Arsenal Should Never Have Signed

Jamie Carragher seems to have changed his opinion about a player he previously believed Arsenal should not have acquired

Former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher once slammed Arsenal for signing a player he deemed unworthy. He was convinced the club had made a mistake. Today, however, his words have taken a surprising turn.

That player is Mikel Merino. Initially, Carragher criticized Arsenal’s decision to bring him in from Real Sociedad, saying Merino wouldn’t make much of an impact. Simple logic, backed by his reputation as a passionate pundit, made it seem like the signing was wrong.

Buy Arsenal's 2025–26 Home Kit through the ArsenalTalks Shop

Click this link to buy the new 2025–26 Arsenal home kit through our ArsenalTalks Shop.

But things changed at Arsenal. Injuries in the team forced manager Mikel Arteta to shift Merino into a different role—one that demanded more from him in attack. In this new role, Merino quickly showcased his talent. Over the last 13 games, he managed to score six goals and notch up four assists. His performance on the pitch not only helped the team secure important wins but also silenced many critics.

Carragher, known for his strong opinions, had to admit that he was blown away by Merino’s transformation. What once looked like a mistake now appears to be a masterstroke. Despite his early doubts, Carragher recognized that Merino’s contributions have become a key reason for Arsenal’s recent success.

This turnaround is a reminder that sometimes players find new ways to shine, especially when the team needs them most. It also highlights that opinions in football can change quickly when a player overcomes expectations.

Carragher’s change of heart is a lesson in keeping an open mind. Even those voices known for certainty can be surprised by the unpredictable twists of the game.