Danny Murphy Makes Controversial Comparison Between Salah and Saka

Danny Murphy Salah vs Saka preference fuels Arsenal-Liverpool rivalry as the winger comparison intensifies this season

Former Premier League midfielder Danny Murphy has sparked heated discussion across Premier League circles after insisting he would still take Mohamed Salah over Bukayo Saka, despite the winger comparison shifting strongly toward Arsenal’s star this season. His stance surprised many Arsenal fans, especially given Saka’s outstanding form and Salah’s noticeable dip under new Liverpool manager Arne Slot.

Murphy delivered the bold statement on talkSPORT, acknowledging Salah’s struggles while still backing the Egyptian’s pedigree. He highlighted Salah’s “unbelievable goals” and his long-term killer instinct as reasons for choosing him in a direct comparison.

Buy Arsenal's 2025–26 Home Kit through the ArsenalTalks Shop

Click this link to buy the new 2025–26 Arsenal home kit through our ArsenalTalks Shop.

The opinion comes as Salah, now 33, has managed only two goals in his last seven Premier League games, with Liverpool drifting in eighth place after eleven matches. Arsenal, meanwhile, continue to push forward under Mikel Arteta, making Murphy’s view even more polarising.

Bukayo Saka’s Rapid Rise Strengthens Arsenal’s Argument

Bukayo Saka, 24, has been in electric form and continues to deliver in big moments for Arsenal. He recently scored in Arsenal’s Champions League win over Slavia Prague and added another in their Premier League draw with Sunderland. His England goal during the international break further displayed his consistency and influence.

With Arsenal currently sitting at the top of the Premier League table, Saka’s output, versatility and leadership make him one of the division’s most complete wingers. Many fans believe Murphy’s loyalty to Salah overlooks the reality of Saka’s soaring trajectory.

Murphy’s remarks immediately set off debate across social media and football panels. Arsenal supporters argue that Saka’s form, youth and all-round contribution make him the clear choice in 2025. Others side with Murphy, pointing to Salah’s winning pedigree, match-winning history and his impact on Liverpool’s major trophies.

The disagreement revived a familiar football question: Do current performances matter more than legacy? Salah’s legacy at Liverpool is immense, but Saka’s rise positions him as one of the Premier League’s most influential attackers today.

Bukayo vs. Salah:Season Snapshot

Although the debate goes beyond numbers, the contrast in form is stark. Saka continues to perform at the highest level in domestic and European matches, while Salah’s influence has dipped along with Liverpool’s overall momentum under Slot. Arsenal’s title challenge places Saka firmly in the spotlight, making the comparison more relevant than ever.

Danny Murphy’s stance may come from admiration for Salah’s established greatness, but the ongoing discussion highlights how rapidly elite football evolves. As Arsenal push for another title challenge and Saka continues to deliver, the Salah–Saka debate will intensify, with many believing the present clearly favours Arsenal’s homegrown star.

Want more Arsenal updates? Visit our homepage.