Alan Shearer Warns Newcastle Over Sandro Tonali Exit as Arsenal Interest Grows

Sandro Tonali Arsenal transfer warning emerges as Alan Shearer claims Newcastle could lose stars if European football slips away.

Alan Shearer has delivered a blunt warning to Newcastle United over the future of Sandro Tonali, as Arsenal interest intensifies around the Italian midfielder.

The Newcastle legend believes failure to qualify for Europe could trigger a summer raid on the club’s top talents — with Tonali firmly on that list.

Buy Arsenal's 2025–26 Home Kit through the ArsenalTalks Shop

Click this link to buy the new 2025–26 Arsenal home kit through our ArsenalTalks Shop.

Speculation surged on deadline day after Tonali was reportedly offered to Arsenal as cover for the injured Mikel Merino.

The move never materialised, and Tonali’s representatives quickly played down the rumours. But the link reignited concerns inside Newcastle’s fanbase about the club’s pulling power if results continue to dip.

Shearer delivers stark message

Speaking to Betfair, Shearer did not hold back.

“If Newcastle aren’t competitive in the Premier League or qualifying for Europe, other clubs will look at them and try to buy their best players.”

Tonali was directly referenced as one of the players elite clubs would target if Newcastle fail to secure Champions League or Europa League football.

Signed from AC Milan for £55m in 2023, Tonali’s time on Tyneside has been turbulent.

A 10-month betting ban, fitness issues, and inconsistent form have disrupted his rhythm. But his technical quality, tactical intelligence, and elite-level pedigree still make him a highly attractive asset — especially for title-chasing clubs like Arsenal.

Tonali is not the only concern.

Shearer’s warning extends to the club’s wider core, with names like Bruno Guimarães also viewed as vulnerable if European qualification is missed.

With financial controls tightening and ambitions rising, Newcastle face a clear pressure point:
perform — or prepare to sell.

Season-defining weeks ahead

Newcastle’s form now carries consequences beyond league position.

Failure to secure Europe doesn’t just hurt prestige — it weakens leverage in the transfer market and strengthens rivals’ hands.

For Tonali, Arsenal interest may have cooled for now. But the signal is clear.

If Newcastle slip, the vultures will circle.

Want more Arsenal updates? Visit our homepage.