Carragher Slams Everton Arsenal Penalty Decision, Ignites VAR Debate After Controversial Draw

Carragher Everton Arsenal penalty verdict fuels VAR debate after controversial decision in 1–1 draw at Goodison Park.

Jamie Carragher shares verdict on Everton penalty against Arsenal with intensify scrutiny over Premier League officiating after Everton earned a controversial spot-kick in their 1–1 draw with Arsenal. Jamie Carragher criticized the decision, calling it “very, very soft” and backing Mikel Arteta’s frustration.

The incident occurred early in the second half when Myles Lewis-Skelly collided with Jack Harrison inside the box. Referee Darren England awarded the penalty, and VAR upheld the call despite replays showing minimal contact. Iliman Ndiaye converted from the spot, leveling the score after Leandro Trossard had given Arsenal the lead.

Speaking on Sky Sports, Carragher expressed disbelief that VAR didn’t overturn the decision. “It’s not about the referee making a horrendous decision; it’s just not a penalty,” he said. Carragher acknowledged Arsenal’s defensive missteps but emphasized that VAR should have intervened to correct the call.

Arteta Shares Carragher’s Frustration

Mikel Arteta reviewed the footage multiple times and found no justification for the penalty. He voiced his disappointment in the post-match press conference, stating that the decision cost Arsenal a vital chance to close the gap on league leaders Liverpool.

The draw leaves Arsenal 11 points behind Liverpool with seven matches remaining. With the Champions League as their only realistic shot at silverware, the Gunners must regroup quickly. Meanwhile, the penalty controversy continues to dominate headlines.

As the Carragher Everton Arsenal penalty debate unfolds, fans and pundits are once again questioning the effectiveness of VAR. Many are calling for reforms to prevent soft decisions from overshadowing key moments in the Premier League.

All links on ArsenalTalks Shop are affiliate links. We may earn commissions that support our content—at no extra cost to you. Read our full Affiliate Disclosure for more information.